Library of risk of bias tools

Evidence-based librarianship critical appraisal checklist

Study design(s) targeted by the tool Observational studies (mixed designs)observational-studies Randomized controlled trials (RCT)randomized-controlled-trial-rct
Additional details on designs Library and information research
Tool area Health; Librarianship
Link to the tool Access the paper reporting the EBL tool

Details

Website
Primary publication Cleyle S, Glynn L (2006), "A critical appraisal tool for library and information research". Library Hi Tech, Vol. 24 No. 3 pp. 387–399
DOI 10.1108/07378830610692154
Guidance document
Training

None known – please contact us if you are aware of any training that should be listed here.

Language English
Translations

None known – please contact us if you are aware of any translations that should be listed here.

Record last updated 08/06/2026

Related tools and Publications

Previous versions

None

Updated versions

None

Related tools

None

Evaluations

None known – please contact us if you are aware of any evaluations that should be listed here.

Other publications

None known – please contact us if you are aware of any publications that should be listed here.

Key Criteria

Focuses on risk of bias, or makes a distinction between items that assess risk of bias and other aspects of study quality No
Offers a method to reach either a domain specific or overall assessment of risk of bias No
Tool developed for use across topic areas (i.e. not developed for specific clinical area such as physiotherapy or dentistry) No
Avoids recommending use of summary numerical quality scores No